Special economic zone in supply chains

(VLR) (Vietnam Logistics Review) Special Economic Zone (SEZ) is a popular investment- attracting model on the world which has created economic development miracles… but not a few of them become a real shame. As experiments, it can become either a success or a failure.

(Vietnam Logistics Review) Special Economic Zone (SEZ) is a popular investment- attracting model on the world which has created economic development miracles… but not a few of them become a real shame. As experiments, it can become either a success or a failure.

Old to the world; new to Vietnam

SEZ is an area within a country in which business and trade laws are different from the rest. Thus, companies operating in the area enjoy particular incentives and privileges. There have been about 4,300 SEZ around the world and the number have been on the increase. Myanmar and Qatar have introduced many SEZs. India Government considered their SEZ ambition “having revolutionary meaning”. And Japanese PM Shinzo Abe confirmed strategic SEZs will be in his economic renovation roadmap.

Those who are interested in SEZs can show some successes of the model. The remarkable one can be that of China, founded in 1980 near Hong Kong, later referred as “Shenzen Miracles”, where Chinese leaders carefully performed their economic renovation policies, before applying them widely nationwide in China.

So, SEZ is definitely nothing new, and definitely not a Vietnam’s creation.

The policy of SEZ was introduced right at the start of Renovation and it was put in document at the Central Resolution 4 term VIII (1997) and then Document of the Party’s Meeting X in 2006. Vung Tau- Con Dao is the first SEZ in Vietnam, founded in 1979 serving the development of oil and gas industry in the condition that our country was still in the planned economy.

In the time of Renovation, started in 1986, SEZs densely appeared in provinces in the Central (as Dung Quat, Chu Lai, Nghi Son, Vung Ang)… They are in form of simple and smallscaled SEZs. These unassertive initial steps were not enough for a breakthrough.

Nguyen Thanh Nghi- Party Secretary, Head of Assembly Delegates of Kien Giang province- recently affirmed the province has prepared the most basic conditions for the forming of Phu Quoc Special Administration- Economic Zone. He also said the province has formed a guiding board and two subcommittees researching the project contents. The preparation has had wide contribution from ministries, sectors, management people, expert, business people and scientists from both local and abroad. The project basically finished, was consented by provincial party, government levels and people of Kien Giang province and was submitted to the Ministry of Interior and Assembly for consideration. “Consented by people” is the way of Kien Giang provincial Party Secretary expressing “approved by the People Committee”. There has been no referendum in Vietnam as a precedent of “being consented”. After mentioning remarkable advantages of Phu Quoc’s, current Kien Giang leaders believed Phu Quoc is able to achieve planned targets when receiving a mechanism of incentive policies and having legalized international competitions.

On November 11th, on the 4th Meeting Session of Assembly term XIV, the Minister of Planning and Investment Nguyen Chi Dung authorized by the Government PM had a presentation on the statement of the project of Laws for Special Administration- Economic Zone. Then, on the evening of the day, delegates had a discussion on the draft law. Ideas showed great determination and concerns as well in building “real” SEZs in Vietnam in forms of successful models in China.

On March 22nd, 2017 the Politburo Committee approved the foundation of three units of Special Administration- Economic Zone: Van Don, Quang Ninh, Bac Van Phong- Khanh Hoa and Phu Quoc- Kien Giang.

Obstacles ahead

The draft plan by the Ministry of Planning and Investment showed many incentives in terms of both regulations and business conditions for investors in the three SEZs in the future. Some have been of no precedents in Vietnam: the choice of using foreign legal system (through agreement) for settling disputes; a lower tax-pay (normally half lower); keeping full budget for development; and the head of SEZ having full authority to decide issues in SEZs… Are these incentives able to attract investors in fields of high-tech, finance, tourisms…? It is a different question!

It is difficult to take SEZ successes from China or Japan to say our SEZs with generous incentives will be our successes. The rate of SEZ success worldwide is 50/50. China and Japan themselves are the world’s second and third largest economies, investors had great driving force to take part in these markets.

In China, new-generation SEZs introduced by President Xi Jing Ping mainly consider local markets their driving force, and they are encouraged to be developing on bases of technology and strict environment standards. Vietnam’s 3 SEZs consider casino development priority and there have been no environment protection strict regulations. “Will they be examples for development?” is an open question. “Does SEZ means Casino?” is still controversial? After “Golf course syndrome” is “casino syndrome”?

It is not simple to turn 3 SEZs to “motive force” of development like China’s cases. In term of trade, there is no much place for an SEZ to push up a country’s economy. With the rate of importexport/ GDP of 180%, we have been considered an open economy. There are many investment incentives in local authority levels.

Developing SEZ is an experiment of administration machine and policies. SEZ is a good place for experiment of regulation and administration innovations. Successes form SEZs as Shenzen, Putong, Santou and Hainan, China is not only economic successes but also policy suggestions that can be applied nationwide. The new suggestions from Kien Giang Party Secretary Nguyen Thanh Nghi on the model of role unification: Party Secretary cum Head of SEZ; unifying Party and local authority organization; reducing workload on social-economic organizations are remarkable. It is obviously convenient that SEZs function as a labs for renovation policies on larger scales.

And as experiments, it can be either a success or a failure, like we were failed to follow the model of Korean Chaebol in building corps from General Company 91, Vietnam. Without pressure of economic efficiency or provincial/ city GDP, we do not calling for investments at all costs, including sectors without priority or having bad impacts to environment as the case of Formosa Ha Tinh. In fact, applying of SEZ means the loss of taxes (at least in short term) due to incentive policies for attracting investment and the possibility of international ‘money wash”.

Therefore, do not put too much expectation to economic values from SEZs. There should be patient observations of policies being applied there and use them as lessons for the country’s development progress. SEZs are model of sustainable development, not a trading-atall-costs economic way like we used to do for dozens of years. When we are able to perform this, SEZs can plays their roles in the economy, creating Vietnam and global logistics chains.

Ý kiến bạn đọc

Chưa có ý kiến nào. Hãy là người để lại ý kiến đầu tiên.

Ý kiến của bạn


Tối thiểu 10 chữTiếng Việt có dấuKhông chứa liên kếtGửi bình luận

Vui lòng nhập mã bảo mật để gửi bình luận lên hệ thống
Gửi bình luận

Nỗi lo luồng cạn sắp được khơi thông với cơ chế mới

Ngày 22/10/2019 lúc 08:17

Công tác nạo vét duy tu theo hình thức khoán duy trì chuẩn tắc trong khoảng thời gian xác định sẽ được thực hiện từ năm 2020.

Phối hợp giải quyết xe hàng nông sản ùn ứ tại cửa khẩu Tân Thanh

Ngày 21/10/2019 lúc 10:21

Ngày 20/10, Thứ trưởng Bộ Nông nghiệp và Phát triển Nông thôn Phùng Đức Tiến cùng đoàn công tác đã đến cửa khẩu Tân Thanh (Lạng Sơn), kiểm tra, chỉ đạo công tác phối hợp giải quyết thủ tục thông quan giữa các đơn vị chức năng Việt Nam và phía Trung Quốc, trước tình trạng nhiều xe hàng nông sản ùn ứ tại cửa khẩu này.

Nhập siêu gần 400 triệu USD trong nửa đầu tháng 10

Ngày 22/10/2019 lúc 09:06

Đang có đà xuất siêu liên tiếp thời gian gần đây, cán cân thương mại bất ngờ đảo chiều trong nửa đầu tháng 10 với con số nhập siêu gần 400 triệu USD.

Tàu chở container chìm trên sông Lòng Tàu: Nhiều hãng tàu thông báo tăng phụ phí

1 Giờ trước

Ngày 19/10/2019, tàu VietSun Intergrity chở 293 container khởi hành từ cảng VIC đi Hải Phòng bị chìm trên sông Lòng Tàu, làm ảnh hưởng tới luồng tàu ra vào cảng khu vực TP. HCM. Trong khi Bộ Giao thông vận tải và các cơ quan liên quan đang nỗ lực tìm cách trục vớt tàu thì một số hãng tàu vận tải container nước ngoài đang hoạt động tại Việt Nam đã thông báo sẽ tăng phụ phí đối với hàng container xuất khẩu.

Vai trò của kinh tế tư nhân ngày càng được công nhận

1 Giờ trước

Sau hơn 30 năm đổi mới, kinh tế tư nhân không chỉ lớn mạnh qua những con số mà đã từng bước được thừa nhận với vai trò dẫn dắt, là động lực quan trọng của nền kinh tế.

Nông sản và các nhóm hàng chủ lực của Việt Nam xuất khẩu đi đâu?

2 Giờ trước

Trung Quốc, Liên minh châu Âu (EU - 28 nước) là những thị trường xuất khẩu nông sản lớn nhất của Việt Nam.

Thời tiết

TP Hồ Chí Minh

Hiện tại


Mây rải rác


25° - 33°

Mây rải rác


25° - 33°

Mưa giông vào buổi chiều


25° - 33°

Mưa giông rải rác

Nguồn: Weathers Underground

Tỷ giá ngoại tệ

Tỷ giá ngoại tệ cập nhật vào 23/10/2019 15:55
Mã NTTiền mặtChuyển khoảnBán
Nguồn: Vietcombank

Giá xăng dầu

Giá xăng, dầu cập nhật ngày 23/10/2019 11:55
Loại xăng dầuĐơn vịGiá vùng 1Giá vùng 2
Dầu hỏaVND/L1525015550
DO 0,001S-VVND/L1652016850
DO 0,05S-IIVND/L1622016540
E5 RON 92-IIVND/L1947019850
Xăng RON 95-IIIVND/L2079021200
Xăng RON 95-IVVND/L2089021300
Nguồn: Petrolimex